Candy Cane Cookie Recipe

Posted by Ali | Thursday December 8, 201112 comments


My Mom used to make these when I was a kid.  My 3 siblings and I would help twist the dough and add the sprinkles or, if I'm being totally honest, fight with each other until they came out of the oven then stuff our faces.  The recipe is from a neighbour but I've tweaked it a bit to avoid using artificial food colouring, which as you know, is the devil.

Ingredients:
1/2 cup Soft Butter
1/2 cup Shortening (I never claimed these were healthy!)
1 cup Icing Sugar
1 Egg
1 1/2 tsp Almond Extract - don't be cheap and buy artificial.  You will taste the difference.
1 tsp Vanilla Extract - again, the real stuff if you please!
2 1/2 cups All Purpose Flour
1/4 tsp Salt
3/4 cup Cocoa
2 Tbsp Brown Sugar
Loads of Sprinkles!



Combine shortening, melted butter and icing sugar.


Beat ingredients until completely smooth.



Slowly stir in the flour with your Mother-in-Law.  This is your cookie dough so it needs to be thoroughly mixed.  Split the dough in half and put in a separate bowl.



Here is where I diverge from our kindly neighbour's recipe.  Her version calls for red food colouring in half of the dough so the candy canes are red and white.  Since red food colouring is now on the Naughty List, I made the other half chocolate by combining cocoa powder, brown sugar and a bit of water in a measuring cup, stirring it into a paste.  The paste is then added into 1/2 of the dough to give it a nice chocolatey colour and taste.  If your chocolate paste is too watery, add more cocoa because the dough needs to be firm enough to work with.



Take a small piece of each colour dough and roll it in your hands forming strips.



Carefully twist the dough into the shape of a Candy Cane.  If you have clammy hands, this may not be the task for you.  Ask someone with nice dry sandpaper like hands (such as myself) to help you out because the dough is a bit greasy and I don't want you be to upset with me.  Remember, it's not the healthiest recipe ever.



Place on a cookie sheet.  You really don't need to grease it.  Take a moment to admire your handiwork, since it took you an hour to make those *&%# candy canes.



Decorate liberally with sprinkles and whatnot.  You can also use crushed candy canes if you want to be extra festive.



Bake at 350 for about 10 minutes or until they have a hint of golden brown.  Eat a few, then give them away to people you love.
More by Ali
More on Home, Recipes, Entertaining, DIY

Facebook Comments


12 Comments

on September 05, 2012  KatelynRose1984  20,704 said:

I make these every single year. It's been in the family for years, and it's such a fun memory. My daughter loves to decorate them, more than she loves eating them.. Yum! Can't wait for the holidays.

on December 12, 2011  Aliza  14,011 said:

These look soo yummy! I would totally eat them all!

on December 11, 2011  jmca  9,275 said:

yum, that looks really good

on December 09, 2011  amyknows  2,352 said:


These are fabulous! Weekend off = Christmas Baking Central! I really appreciate you tweaking the recipe to remove red food colouring! Can't wait to test em out! :)

on December 09, 2011  takanikki  2,265 said:

Mmmm, these would barely last 15 minutes in my house. Looks so yummy! :D

on December 08, 2011  takoda  28,648 said:

You guy's are all just to funny today, but I like the idea of giving a
few away and eating the rest your self and Ali I love your
directions!!LOL

They look very yummy and I think I just might have every thing in the house to make some up tonight. Thanks for the recipe Ali.

on December 08, 2011  LadyChick234234  3,701 said:


Mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm.

on December 08, 2011  Ali de Bold  STAFF said:

Becky, that is too funny! I bet you're right ;)

on December 08, 2011  Becky  13,128 said:

Ali I lol'ed reading your directions.. but it's all good, my coworker's are used to my weirdness. Can you believe our VP of IT asks me on a weekly basis how chickadvisor is doing? I won't be surprised if he's secretly joined ..lol They look soooooo good!!!! mmm.... thanks to you I'm now craving walkers butter biscuits...sigh

on December 08, 2011  Ali de Bold  STAFF said:

Yep, I said that because otherwise you will find yourself eating several a day until they are gone. Which is exactly what I've been doing ;)

Add Comment:

Name:
Blog URL: