Dessert: Easy 'No-Bake' Peanut Butter Chocolate Pie Recipe

Posted by Diana | Tuesday May 28, 201317 comments


If I were tasked with bringing dessert to a summer BBQ, chances are I would walk in (proudly!) with fudge oat bars from Starbucks. I have never been much of a baker. However, after watching The Pioneer Woman last weekend, I couldn't pass up the opportunity to try making what looked like the most mouth-watering dessert ever. What drew me in was the no-bake factor (obviously), but most of all the chocolaty, peanut-buttery ingredients. This is without a doubt the best "pie" I've ever had, and it's perfect for summer!
 

Ingredients:

4 Tbsp butter
25 oreo cookies
1 cup smooth peanut butter
1 1/4 icing sugar
8 oz cream cheese
8 oz cool whip

What you'll need: 
Pie dish (I used a glass Pyrex one)
Mixer
Food processor

Directions: 

Melt the 4 tbsp of butter on low heat, remove from heat and let cool. 


Crush the 25 Oreo cookies in a food processor and then add the melted butter to create the crust. 


Shape the mixture into a pie pan and place in a preheated oven at 350 degrees for 5-7 minutes. Let the crust cool on the counter or even faster, in the fridge. 


In a mixer, mix the peanut butter and cream cheese. Add in the icing sugar. At this point the mixture will appear very dry but don't be discouraged; the cool whip makes it very light and creamy again. 


On medium speed, add in the cool whip (let it sit out for a bit beforehand so it's not frozen). 


Once you have your mixture, spread it over the crust and then refrigerate for at least 3 hours. 


Here's a tip I discovered: For a "pie" texture, serve after refrigerated. For a thicker "cheesecake" texture, follow the refrigeration instruction but then place in the freezer before serving for about 30 more minutes. 

(Photos by Diana Petrina, title image via ingredientsofa20something.com)
More by Diana
More on Recipes, Entertaining, Food

Facebook Comments


14 Comments

on October 13, 2015  Kylee  40,914 said:

I'm definitely going to be making this recipe! I love peanut butter and I love chocolate so this looks like heaven to me, I am saving this recipe to try

on August 04, 2014  carriejill  1,855 said:

Looks good going to have to try it

on June 23, 2013  so_adorkable_  2,602 said:

Ive made this for my boyfriend a few times and he LOVES it, thanks!

on June 07, 2013  JustUsGirls  3,263 said:

MmMmmmm!LOOKS DELICIOUS! I made a frozen lemonade ice cream cake a few weeks ago, but this sounds even better than that. Will definitely be making this over the Summer!

on May 31, 2013  lovelydays  3,649 said:

This looks insanely good!

on May 30, 2013  smiley_gen  9,832 said:

Drooooooooooool

on May 28, 2013  Ali de Bold  STAFF said:

Do you have any idea how hard it is to read this as a pregnant woman? I need this now and it's 11pm. Yummmmmmmy!

on May 28, 2013  flower  4,433 said:

watch out hips!!

on May 28, 2013  LissaG  6,010 said:

All I can say is ... nomnomnom!

on May 28, 2013  KatelynRose1984  20,704 said:


I make something quite similar to this, but it's with cream cheese - so it's almost like cheese cake.

Add Comment:

Name:
Blog URL: