I try other liquid liners and always come back to this one. I use the bronze colour for blue eyes. It's not too harsh of a colour but does accentuate my eyes but not harsh like black can be. It has great staying power and never smears. You can make a thick or thin line depending on how heavy handed you are with the tip. Have been wearing it for years!!

This is a great liquid, black eyeliner. This was my first, ever liquid eyeliner that I have purchased. I felt this was a very great brand. The only problem someone may have with this product, is how it's liquid or If whenever you're putting it on, you need a steady hand. If you don't have a steady hand, it's hard to put it on properly. But, you have control with the hands and fingers you have which is great. And, you can control the thickness by how hard you place it on yourself.

As far as what's available for liquid eyeliners, I think this is very good. It goes on easily, it's nice and bold looking, it doesn't flake off. The applicator has a nice point so it's easy to get it exactly where you want it. I like the brown because it's not too dark or too light. As far as it being water resistant, no way... On some really hot days last summer, it ran. When my favorite cat in the world died recently, trust me, it did not hold up to my tears! I wish it really was water resistant because then it would be perfect.

Soooooo disappointed with this eyeliner!!!! I bought this because a makeup "guru" on youtube recommended it as a great, matte eyeliner. Perfect!! I thought. I love matte eyeliner so I gave it a shot.

Application was a pain in the ***!! The felt tip is really hard and unflexible, so it actually hurt and was really difficult to get a nice smooth line. As for the colour, it is very black and definitely matte, that is the ONE thing that I like about it. I wore it to work one day and by the middle of the day it was smudged all around my eyes, it looked horrible! I've never had a problem with liquid eyeliner smudging, or fading at all really.. so I was surprised.

Overall I can't believe how horrible this eyeliner is, and I really don't understand why someone recommended it on youtube. Save your money!!! There are WAY better liquid liners out there.

I am not an expert at all with applying liquid eyeliner. My hands are a little shaky especially when applying liquid eyeliner but when I traced it on my top lid the precise tip made it easier for me to apply. I found that it stayed on well and did not smudge like other liquid eyeliners I have used.

This is by far the best liquid eyeliner I have ever tried. It glides on effortlessly and is very precise in its application. The liner lasted all day and I also noticed it is smudge proof and did not flake. It did not irritate my eyes at all. It comes in a little pot with the applicator pen inside it. Easy to hold and I do not find my hand to be wobbling as I put it on. Great for creating dramatic thick lines, or for those who prefer thin lines as well. Only available in 2 shades (brown and black), but well worth every penny. I'll be stocking up on these!

I was hoping this eyeliner would work as they advertise it. This is supposedly water-resistant. I am in total disagreement of that claim. I wore this to a nice dinner, conversation was going very well, and I was laughing to the point of having tears in my eyes. Then all of a sudden I have eye liner running in the inner corner of my eye. I've never had any other product come off so fast as this! Dear Almay, I hope you fix your liquid liner. I love your other makeup products, but this one left me so disappointed.