Not bad

A pretty good eyeliner overall. I have this in black, and it goes on smoothly and is quite easy to apply (but not idiot proof - practice first!)...my only qualm with this product is the fact that it doesn't last long, so it smudges - I had a waterproof liquid eyeliner before this one and it (obviously) lasted longer, so that's what I'm going back to after I finish this.

decent

I like the short tip. Makes it easy to work with and control. I wish there was a little less liquid on the applicator but it is workable. For the price it is a good buy. I also have sensitive eyes and it doesn't irritate them.

This liner is great and not very expensive. I buy the shades they recommend for your eye colour and it goes on smooth. The tip of the liquid brush is the perfect size to get your look just right

This liquid liner goes on smooth and never disappoints.

This is a great liquid, black eyeliner. This was my first, ever liquid eyeliner that I have purchased. I felt this was a very great brand. The only problem someone may have with this product, is how it's liquid or If whenever you're putting it on, you need a steady hand. If you don't have a steady hand, it's hard to put it on properly. But, you have control with the hands and fingers you have which is great. And, you can control the thickness by how hard you place it on yourself.

As far as what's available for liquid eyeliners, I think this is very good. It goes on easily, it's nice and bold looking, it doesn't flake off. The applicator has a nice point so it's easy to get it exactly where you want it. I like the brown because it's not too dark or too light. As far as it being water resistant, no way... On some really hot days last summer, it ran. When my favorite cat in the world died recently, trust me, it did not hold up to my tears! I wish it really was water resistant because then it would be perfect.

I am not an expert at all with applying liquid eyeliner. My hands are a little shaky especially when applying liquid eyeliner but when I traced it on my top lid the precise tip made it easier for me to apply. I found that it stayed on well and did not smudge like other liquid eyeliners I have used.