I used to really like these make up remover pads until I tried Micellar water. It's okay for removing eyeshadow, but it's not very good at removing stubborn mascara, let alone of the waterproof variety. Nor is it very good at removing eyeliner without heavily wiping it. Also, once I near the bottom of the product, I find that the wipes are more prone to irritating my eyes. In the past I would have recommended this product, but now I know there are better products out there.