This was the first Annabelle product I purchased, just a regular black pencil eye liner. Immediately I was not very impressed, it came out very light when applying. Even when trying to use lots of pressure, it wasn't as dark as I had hoped. Also I noticed after I applied, that my eyes began getting very watery and blurry, not sure if I was maybe allergic to one of the ingredients, but I had to remove it right away.

I used to love this eyeliner but, it smears and it does not stay in place
The eyebrow is much better though.... love that one

The eyeliner sucks