I generally dislike eye makeup removers because they are usually too oily while not especially effective. This coming from someone who rarely wears waterproof makeup (so that is rarely the culprit).

The new eye makeup remover lotion from Annabelle is the best I've ever used. It has a pump applicator which is so easy to use, and takes off all of my eye makeup without leaving an oily residue behind. You need to use those cotton pads (any type) with the applicator - if you use Qtips or tissue, it will squirt everywhere.

The price is right inline with what other drugstore brands charge, but as I say the effectiveness (at least for my needs) is superior. I definitely recommend it!