I have been looking for a brow liner that came in a nice dark red shade to tone nicely with my red hair and Annabelle was the only one I could find. It's not too bad really. The colour is nice, deep and it stayed on all day pretty much. My only thought is they could make the product a tiny bit softer to glide on and blend really well. I found it a little rigid and had to press firmly for it show up on my skin. Otherwise it was a pretty good buy and love supporting a Canadian company.