Both the regular & waterproof version of this liner are amazing! In particular, I love the waterproof one for drawing on lines on the lids of my eyes. This is better than the conventional liners because it doesn't smudge in the crease of your eye and it lasts a lot longer too!

I rarely give more than a 3 for ratings, however, this kohl pencil is absolutely amazing, the price is ridiculously inexpensive, and the quality is superb. I use this eyeliner in "Skore" and its great to use as both an eyeliner and a brow pencil if you area brunette. I would definately recommend this product.

Wow, I can't believe the bad experience you had with this eyeliner Rabby! It is literally one of my favourite products. Its is one of the only cosmetics I have stuck with for years and years. I love this eyeliner so much. I use the black pencil for lining my upper (and sometimes lower) lash line, and I have always found it to be soft and creamy. It also doesn't smudge like some eyeliners can, and its doesn't tug at your eyelids when you're applying it. My only problem with it is that it doesn't wash off that easily with cleanser. There always seems to be a teensy little bit of it left on my eyes even after washing my face and using toner.

However I also should mention, that I always use this liner in black. I tried it recently in a purple colour just for fun, and it wasn't nearly as creamy and soft as all my black ones have been.

All in all though, I don't think I will ever switch eyeliners because this one works so well for me, and its only 4 bucks!

i've tried many eyeliners from rimmel, maybelline n de all melted n spread n all my eyes became black!!! dis is da probs dat i face...all da eye liners melt because of da heat. when i tried annabelle smooth liner (or something like this) it was excellent!! it stayed on da whole day even in da heat!!

anyway pls someone tell me da exact name of dat eyeliner...i think it's annabelle smooth liner...but i donnot the full name of it. i don't live in canada so i wanna order it...pls help me!!

I love the array of colours that are available! At that price how can you go wrong?

Greatest eyeliner I have ever used. It glides on so easily and dramatically. It's also great if you take a q-tip and smudge it into your lashline, and it doesn't fade. Plus it's so cheap!!

Ouch!!

The last thing I expected when I bought this, gazing at the soft-looking coloured tip, was that when I went to apply it I would immediately pull it away from my face, looking for where the wood of the pencil had slipped into the liner. No sign. But I could have sworn I just rubbed the delicate lid of my eye with a piece of wood! It scraped! It hurt! It... Was actually the liner itself. This stuff was SO HARD it hurt to apply. Wetting the tip didn't help either.

Not only that, but when I persisted, tried to put it on anyway, it was so hard the tip broke right off. Okay. So there I was left with a piece of sharp wood in one hand, and a tiny nib of eye liner in my fingers of the other. Well, maybe this was a good bit of progress? I rubbed the kohl between my finger and thumb to warm and smooth it out so I might just apply it with my fingers instead. Once the consistency was relatively creamy, I tried. Did that work? Not really. It came off my fingers in clumps and was far from what I could possibly call attractive. This was one of the most painfully disappointing products I've tried and I will never risk that again. There's not much pleasant about rubbing something that feels like raw wood around your eyes - and the colour doesn't even come off the stick onto your eyes. And then it breaks off. Lovely. Never again.

I've used this eye liner for the last 7 years and I love it! It was my mom's favourite brand, and when I started wearing makeup I started using the same product. I love it. It lasts all day, doesn't run or smudge(unless you start rubbing your eyes) and it doesn't irritate your eyes.