Annabelle kohl liners go on smoothly and the colour is true to the colour advertised. They are perfect for the smokey eye and I love the range of colours they come in, both jewels and metallics. I would highly recommend it.

I love this eyeliner in white, although I have also tried the brown. I use this pencil in my waterline and I've noticed that the colour is very buildable and lasts the better part of the day. I use it almost every day and it has been my favourite liner for my waterline so far.

This is one of my top go to drugstore eyeliners. There are a ton of colors to choose from and they glide over skin effortlessly without smudging. These liners are very soft but you can still get a pretty thin line out of them, or go a thick as you want. The pigmentation is exceptional, and will last a good part of the day/night, but you wont have to worry about any staining or spending a ridiculous amount of time trying to remove it.
The price is what I would would expect to pay at the drugstore, but what you get for the price is amazing. I really think Annabelle is an underrated company. I find myself reaching for this liner over many others around the same price range. They also sharpen nicely (maybe an odd observation but I can't stand pencil that are too brittle and splinter, or are too soft and over-sharpen without even getting that perfect pointy tip).
The only problem I've had with them (and I'm not sure if it's because the end dries out or when it gets wet) is that once in a while, when I go to reapply, instead of laying down color - nothing happens. It doesn't scratch off any makeup already there, but it's like there's a layer of plastic covering the kohl. But, all you have to do is sharpen it and it's good to go.

I got this eyeliner in a gift basket for my birthday and I actually use it daily. I like how smoothly it goes on and how long it lasts me through out the day. It also smudges on me nicely to give me a smokey look. I would definitely recommend it for first time eyeliner users because this was the eyeliner I used to learn.

Great product from a Canadian company. Annabelle has really increased quality lately, and I picked a few of these up to try out and love them. Staying power is pretty good, you'll need touch up to get you into the evening but for a general liner for all day wear, this works nicely.

I have been using Annabelle eyeliner for many, many years and I love it still. I was in Grade 7 when I was allowed to start wearing Make-up, what a treat that was. Girls today seem to have a much better grasp on the art of applying make-up, for me it was black all around the eye. ( I looked so cool ) umm, No. Annabelle was always there for me like an old friend, when I needed a boost to my look, or I just wanted to add some colour to my eyes I would reach for the annabelle.
Now that I am much older and a little wiser I still find myself coming back to Annabelle, I will try other's, but I always keep my Annabelle close. The colours are vivid, bright and beautiful. I find the pencil easy to work with and easy to apply, never clumpy and easy to sharpen. I could always count on it. You will always find it in my makeup stash.

This is the eyeliner I use for my black, it's the darkest black i've found and it stays on all day!

I got this a few months ago, thinking it was a soft shimmery gray but the name is actually Black Pearl (115).
It is a bit different than the shade I was expecting, but still nice! It's kind of a charcoal shimmer I guess.
When I first tried this out I noticed it felt really dry compared to other eye liners I've used. Because of this, it doesn't seem to 'glide' on like other products either, but I can live with that.
I've tried smudging this to make a kind of smokey effect, but it doesn't work well. It comes off, but doesn't really move around, which is a good thing anyway if you don't want raccoon eyes halfway through your day/night.
For the price and the staying power this has, I would recommend it. But I don't think I will buy again, personally - I think I prefer something that feels softer.

This khol eyeliner did not agree with my eyes at all. I have asian eyes that fold in more, so it's hard to find eyeliners that won't smudge after a day's wear. However, this eyeliner smudged off after an hour or two and after a day of wearing it, disappeared. It left me pretty frustrated. I know my eyes have a lot to do with how well the liners stay on, but I've definitely tried better.

Personally I love this product there is a downside that I will get to. But these were on sale for around $3 and Annabelle had coupons on their site for $2 off so I stocked up on them. I love the quality of this eyeliner because it is very pigmented unless NYC and it seems to last for a while. And gives my eyes this special pop that I love.

Two downsides of this product is 1) the eyeliner does not have a plastic wrapper on the top which I emailed to let them know about. Because out of the 3 eyeliners I purchased 2 seemed to be used and it was not hygenic at all. Secondly I found this eyeliner to irritate my eyes. It left my eyes blurry and stung and kind of felt liek a billion eyelashes had fallen into it. I don't know if it is was only for me but I let my mom try it and she said the same.

That being said I still tolerate it because I love this product too much to even think about switching back to my other brands :)