These pencils have been a staple in my makeup case for years! I think I'm on my 3rd black one, I just love them so much. These lasted through my phase of piling on the eyeliner instead of eyeshadow with minimal creasing and now that I use these to create a much more elegant, softer look they work great too. I picked up a brown one as well and tried some other colours over the years. Overall, adore this product! Especially when it goes on sale at PharmaPlus - 1.99 or 2.99 the last time I bought them!

The waterproof version is my go-to eyeliner. It lasts all day, and can't be beat for the price! I love the colour selection, although my favourite is black!

I love these eyeliners! My mom uses them too. They come in great colours, go one great and tend to stay put well enough for my liking. I don't think they are horribly priced either. My only issue is that I often have to drive an hour to purchase them as most of the places that sell cosmetics near me don't carry them or don't carry a very large selection...but not a huge problem as i pick them up when i need them and often drive the same distance for others things too.

Annabelle kohl eyeliner is my new love!! Trust me, I am probably one of the hardest eyeliner critics.. but this stuff is amazing! With every other eyeliner I have tried, either I couldn't get the product to apply so it looked suitable to be seen in or it smudged within a few hours.. although I admit it may not be the product and rather my terrible eyeliner applying skills. However, this eyeliner goes on really smoothly and lasts quite a while! Plus, there is a huge color selection and they have great pigmentation. The annabelle kohl eyeliner was on sale for 2.99 so I picked up three shades, and I'm not disappointed with any of them! This is a fantastic product.

I love this eyeliner. No matter what brand I've tried I've always went back to Annabelle brand. It goes on smoothly and stays on all day which is huge for me as a busy mom. I highly recommend this brand of eyeliner.

It was amazingly inexpensive, yet very smooth gliding and long lasting.

I’ve tried a lot of pencil eyeliner, but this one is the best. It doesn’t smudge in the crease of your eye & plus it lasts longer then other eyeliners. It’s great use as bother eyeliner and a brow pencil. It’s a good price, not to expensive & the prices vary from the certain place you buy it from. I would definitely recommend this!

Both the regular & waterproof version of this liner are amazing! In particular, I love the waterproof one for drawing on lines on the lids of my eyes. This is better than the conventional liners because it doesn't smudge in the crease of your eye and it lasts a lot longer too!

I rarely give more than a 3 for ratings, however, this kohl pencil is absolutely amazing, the price is ridiculously inexpensive, and the quality is superb. I use this eyeliner in "Skore" and its great to use as both an eyeliner and a brow pencil if you area brunette. I would definately recommend this product.

Wow, I can't believe the bad experience you had with this eyeliner Rabby! It is literally one of my favourite products. Its is one of the only cosmetics I have stuck with for years and years. I love this eyeliner so much. I use the black pencil for lining my upper (and sometimes lower) lash line, and I have always found it to be soft and creamy. It also doesn't smudge like some eyeliners can, and its doesn't tug at your eyelids when you're applying it. My only problem with it is that it doesn't wash off that easily with cleanser. There always seems to be a teensy little bit of it left on my eyes even after washing my face and using toner.

However I also should mention, that I always use this liner in black. I tried it recently in a purple colour just for fun, and it wasn't nearly as creamy and soft as all my black ones have been.

All in all though, I don't think I will ever switch eyeliners because this one works so well for me, and its only 4 bucks!