This product does last long, and is creamy, but it's too creamy. The pencil is quite thick so it's hard to draw a thinner line. It's also frustrating to sharpen it because the consistency is so buttery. I would much prefer to use this as a base for a smoky eye.. but I have other products I do that with, so I will not be purchasing it again.
I much prefer eye liners that are thinner and do not require sharpening.

These eyeliners are my favorite! They are available in a matte or metallic finish. Waterproof, Long-lasting and Hypo-Allergenic. I've been purchasing them for years and I always go back to them because I love the smooth,creamy application they provide. No tugging on my eyes and they always look great. They generally run you around $7 but I usually get them on sale at Shoppers Drug Mart. I love the depth of color the Black eyeliner gives to my hazel eyes but my favorite eyeliner out of the bunch is Bronze. It makes my eyes stand out like no other eyeliner and it is great especially when smudged for a quick and easy smokey look.

When it comes to eyeliner i had such a hard time finding one that went on smoothly and would last. One of my friends swore by Annabelle and even went out and bought me the eyeliner just so I would try it. Its times when i go out and I don't have to fight with my eyeliner that i truly know i have great friends

LOVE this eyeliner! I honestly have had it for so long I dont even wanna repeat how long lol, but its lasted and is down to the last little bit, this is why I appreciate the old school version of having to sharpen pencils because when their good, they last forever! its very smooth just like the name and waterproof as well! just have to let it dry after applying is its only downfall.

I received this liner to review in 'metal daze'. It's called "Smoothliner" and it definitely lives up to it's name. It goes on very smoothly and just glides over your lid. This also makes it pretty good for smudging, it makes for a good smoky eye. It doesn't fade either and takes quite a bit of effort to wash off- so great for all day wear.

I don't spend a lot on my make up, specifically my eyeliner. I use a lot of black eye liner as well so I don't know if I would purchase a $7 liner instead of 3 $2.50 liners though.

This is a great eye liner for the price. It goes on smooth unlike some eye liners that pull on your lid. Colour stays on throughout the day. The only con: That it is not water or smudge proof. So if you rub your eye, it will smire. But for the price (especially when it is on sale), you can afford to carry an extra one around with you.

I have this liner in black and its goes on nice and dark, however it smudges very easily. I would only use this to apply liner at the top of my eyelid, but definitely not on the waterline. It would run within minutes. I was quite disappointed as the brow pencils are excellent, but not so much the liners.

eyeliner is my best friend :P if i had to pick one cosmetic to wear everyday, that would be it! i had tried covergirl and other brands of eyeliner. buying this one was just a desperate last resort. i put it on and realized it was waterproof. i had tried waterproof eyeliner before and they had NEVER work. my face is also VERY oily and as soon as i got halfway through my day, my eyeliner would be al over my face! this eyeliner was great to have on and seemed great to apply. i made it through my day without looking like i had two black eyes! i have no complaints about this eyeliner!