I am so in love with this smudge liner. I got it in Rich Chocolate. It's a gorgeous colour and basically an instant smokey eye for the sultry look. What's also amazing is that you can use the smudging end on other eyeliners as well (doesn't work as well but better than using your fingers). The colour goes on strong and smoothly, I have zero complaints. Just be careful not to apply too much eyeliner to smudge because then it just looks messy.