I have almost every shade and I will never trade this for any others. The quality and the amount alone has kept me loyal since the beginning. Stays on all day, easy to use and I love the boldness of color.

I have difficulty wearing eye liner; I find it smudges very easily. Liquid eyeliner is a challenge for me to apply; therefore I don't use it. However I found the Annabelle Smudge very easy to use whether applying a thin or thicker line. The only drawback was that I had to make sure I kept my eyes wide open until the eyeliner was completely dry; my eyes are deepset and eyeliner has a tendency to smudge on me.

I absolute love Annabelle Smudge paint!!
I find liquid eye liners to be difficult to apply but at the same time am not fussy of the look of a pencil liner.
This product solved all of that for me!
It looks GREAT on - just like a liquid liner!
But where it's thicker than a liquid liner, it's easier to apply!
And the brush is so handy because it snaps inside the cover
This also makes it easy to keep clean!
I highly recommend this! :)

I used this eyeliner yesterday and I was extremely surprised by how smooth it is. I usually use the Smashbox cream eyeliner and the consistency is a bit hard. With this, I can just pick up some by dipping it into the pot easily and it goes on your skin very nicely. I liked it so much that I will continue to purchase this. This eyeliner is also good if you want to use the brush and smudge it up for a quick smokey eyeshadow effect. Btw, I got the black one courtesy of Annabelle.

I'm personally a huge fan of the cat's eye. However, it can sometimes be hard to achieve. I haven't quite mastered the perfect liquid liner line, and have been on the hunt for a good gel liner for a while now. While in WalMart last week I stumbled upon this beauty in the Annabelle section. Available in 5 colours, I went for tar, the nice black shade. I found the consistency to be extremely nice, more "liquid-y" than other gel or cream liners I've tried. It went on extremely smoothly, and once it dried, it wasn't going anywhere, probably due to the fact that it is waterproof. It stayed on all day, and didn't budge. It comes with a liner brush in the handle of the container, however I had problems with this as it is very narrow and I prefer to use my own liner brush with it to create a slightly thicker line. All in all, great product.