I always use the glimmerstick (waterproof) for eyeliner. They have a lots of color available and of course the black one.
I like that they are retractable and they have a great price. They are also available as lipliners and for eyebrows. I use them for years

While these do tend to vary in quality by colour, they are soft on application but not so much that they break easily, do not easily smudge once dry (you can smudge them out if done immediately after application) and wear well.

Great price for eyeliner. I love that it's retractable. so many shades to choose from. The staying power is pretty good too. I also use it for my eyebrows. Works really well.

Such a great price for eye liner. And there are so many colours to choose from. Unfortunately this product is not for me. I cough a lot during the day. And when I go into big coughing fits my eyes tend to water. Which makes the liner smudge and does not last for me.

The eyeliner really lives up to its name! not only does it leave a nice sheen, it's long lasting! great for long day or night big time.. also you cant go wrong with the deal you get :)

The first time I tried this product I knew I had picked a winner. No need to sharpen it and all you have to do is twist it up. I will never go back to any other brand. It is fantastic! You can also smudge it on your eyes as a eyeshadow.

I love this eye liner. It is very easy to use and creates a flawless eye look. I love the pigmentation of the colour and how it lasts all day without moving or smudging.

I really love these liners, they have so many great colours. The price for these is unbelievable. I love the way they go on and last the whole day with no smudges. The best part is you never need a sharpener.

I LOVE this eye liner. It never dries out. You never have to sharpen it and it goes on so smooth and easy. I bought it about 3 months ago and I will never buy another eye liner again. Totally recommend this product to everyone. For the price you can't go wrong. It feels like a 50$ eyeliner when you put it on.

Love, Love, Love this eyeliner! It's so easy to apply, doesn't smudge, and is a steal price wise! The best part is you never need a sharpener. I only use this product now.