This was a fun liner to use to enhance the corners of my eyes. I still stand by black liquid liners for my upper eyelids, but for trying out other colours this is a good line, especially for being a pencil type. It twists out of the tube so you never have to sharpen it. And its a soft creamy kohl formula that glides right on without having to repeat a spot or keep running it back and forth. I'm using the bronze shade and it's nicely metallic and a lot like a precise high-end eyeshadow in appearance.