My second choice

Been my go to for years! It does a great job.

It goes on nicely and definitely builds well. It does get clumpy after a bit. Dries out in the tube as well.

Wasn't the best wasn't the worst . Did the job for a night out but a bit extreme for anything else

Works so well. I have naturally long lashes and this just made them fuller an dark

My roommate hates black mascara, I on the other hand love it. So we swapped. I gave her my colossal lash (which I hated) in a brown color and she gave me this in blackest black. It typically cost 15$ so a little more than a drugstore mascara, but the wand is so amazing. It gives my dark dramatic full lashes that go on for days. it almost looks as if I am wearing fakes they are so perfect. hardly any clumping, just long full lashes.

this mascara really does the job without flaking off. the brush is the secret I believe.