My Friend gave me this as a gift......I love Benefit , the packaging is super cool and the products are great!!! Does not go on too thick , thinner than it appears and it glids on ....!!!!

The pencil is ok. I am trying to get used to the thickness of it. But it is easy to grab as it is thick. It smudges a little bit, to create a smoky, smolderin eye effect.. It doesn't stay on the water line though. It makes great punky looks, but other than that it is not the best.

Great product, it's perfect for that "smoky eye" look. It is smooth and blendable. I wore it with powder eyeshadow so I didn't notice the creasing that was described it the other review but I can see how that could happen because of the consistency of the liner.

This eyeliner has its advantages...it goes on very smoothly and makes a thick smoky line. The reason I cannot recommend it (and maybe it's just me) is that it looked great for only a short time because it always ended up making a black smudge on my upper lid. Maybe I've just got oily lids and someone else wouldn't have this problem. Aside from its inability to stay put, I would've liked this product.