This is one of my top 5 eyeliners. It has a great consistency, as well as the brush applies the liner so perfectly. No disappointments with this eyeliner as it is a great price as well.

Lately my eyelids have become more oily and I have problems keeping eye liner on my waterline, so I've had to stop using most "regular" eyeliners. I recently received the BADgal waterproof liner free to test and so far I'm really happy with it.

The pencil is slightly harder to apply, as if the product is a little more waxy, but still very easy to use. There is a smudging tool on the back end that I appreciate. Best of all, it lives up to the waterproof claim very well. For a day at the pool or beach it will wear somewhat, especially if you rub your eyes of course, but for everyday and sweating, it's a perfect product.

A little pricey but I do recommend it!

I like this eyeliner. It goes on really black and it lasts pretty long (8 hours or so) although I wish it would last longer. It has a blending tip on the other end and it's nice to have when you feel like creating a smokey look. If you like wearing the smokey look often then I would recommend this eyeliner. I still think Urban Decay's eyeliner is better. It lasts longer. But this is a good quality eyeliner.