This is my fave brow pencil. It has a slanted applicator so that makes it perfect for people who are just starting out in filling in their brows and not so sure on how to shape them. It also comes with a spoolie brush on the other end so you can fluff out your brows and soften your look. I deff recommend this product!

I love the goof proof pencil compared to other eyebrow products because it gives you the perfect amount of product without having your brows jumping off your face,only downside i noticed is that it isnt cruelty free

Anyone who knows me knows that I am not a big makeup person. I do however have really light and sparse eyebrows and until now, never had the nerve to try to do something about them. This product was made for me!! It is SO easy to apply, even for a clutz like me and it really does look natural. I am always afraid of over doing my makeup but this pencil goes on easily and looks good, subtle yet I finally have nice eyebrows!!

I think Benefit has me as a customer for life. Seriously!

Benefit does a great job with selecting your perfect brow color, and I like how this pencil really is goof proof. However, since I have oily skin, this product would smudge off quickly. I also found the pencil too soft and felt I was using up the product too fast. I think this would work best for those with normal to dry skin.

I love it for my thick brows. The different shape of the pencil is something to get used to, and I also wasn't really excited about the price either. It still is my favorite brow pencil though, so I am sure I will buy it again. I love the staying power of it though.

This is a great option for those of us who have somewhat full brows already, but need a little help filling in or shaping the tails. It gives me a really natural looking shape and texture. I probably wouldn't use this for dramatic brow days, but it's a great option for everyday.

So exciting to try out a couple of the new Benefit Brow offerings after using up my older products but I'm a little torn. I'm a little on the fence about the Goof Proof Brow Pencil ~ very precise and a thin line product. Goof Proof is supposed to replace my faithful and much loved Instant Brow Pencil that I've happily been using for like forever (I've purchased and sharpened my way through far too many to count) so not quite sure if I'm feeling the love with this new pencil ~ different! Goof Proof is awesome in that it doesn't need sharpening so you're not wasting any product and it's also being offered in more shades than the original Instant Brow. Love the spoolie end as well. Maybe I just need to get used to a thinner filler pencil and feather more for a natural look?

Agreed with the previous reviewer about being overpriced, but - it's definitely a good product. Application is easy, the shape makes it easy to fill in brows, etc.

The packaging is very cute. It has a spoolie on one end and the pencil is angled for definition. It’s also waterproof which is great. The pencil is actually kind of a sharp pair/diamond shape, so as far as definition goes I think I would just prefer a straight, angled pencil like the ABH Brow Definer. This applied smoothly and the colour was great. This product is $30 and I’m not sure I will ever understand how they justify charging that much for a brow pencil from any brand.

Benefit is one of the best beauty companies on the market for brow products, so I decided the splurge of $30 was justified to try out their Goof Proof brow pencil. The pencil comes in 6 shades, ranging from Fair to Dark. Application was simple, and the pencil was pigmented but not too overly dramatic. The formula glides on smoothly and stays put all day. It comes with a spoolie bush to tame your brows and shape/enhance them even further. Overall, I wouldn't pay a whopping 30 bucks for a brow pencil, so I probably won't be buying the full sized pencil again. They currently offer a deluxe sample size for a discounted price, so check that out if you don't want to spend the $30 to try it out. I would recommend this product for anyone who wants to give their brows a little more definition, colour, and shape.