Not my favourite..... Super thick and makes lashes very clumpy and spidery.... To dark and messy

I tend to stay away from the high-end mascaras, because A) they are expensive and B) I'm almost always disappointed. I received a sample of this mascara when it first came and I love it. Though it doesn't give a curl per se, like when you use a lash curler, it gives you a lot of volume and length and hold the curl pretty well. Sephora has a mini size if you prefer to try it first.

Clumps, sticky and goops like crazy when I apply it.
Unfortunately this mascara did very little for my lashes.
did not curl my lashes
packaging was cute
I felt like this was hard to easily wash off

Finally a mascara that works for me. I have short lashes that point down and this mascara really helps keeping them up all day once they are curled. I got this mascara in april, and one thing that i noticed is that it did not change consistency since I used it first time. Love the brush and the definition it gives.

after using this all the time for a while now I have realized how much I absolutely love Benefit Roller Lash mascara and I know it's quite expensive and a few people have said that they wouldn't buy it because of the price but I think it is really worth the investment! You really notice the difference from your previous mascara when you first use this and with the two style brush you are able to build up length from the base of your lashes with the short straight part of the brush and then use the curved edge with more bristles to add volume for a full feathered long lash, it's honestly like magic! Benefit also said that if you use the Benefit They're Real mascara on top you can build up an amazing false lash look, the only down side to this is though that because this mascara is made for building up it doesn't harden and dry like other mascara which means it's super soft all day, quite clay like but it does mean you can build it up any time during the day! I haven't tried this mascara with an eyelash curler because it says you don't need one on the packaging but I wonder if it would make them better! I am almost finished this mascara and I'm excited to get my hands on a new one and maybe give They're Real a go on top too!

Looooove this mascara, lengthens my lashes super duper well. Keeps my lashes curled all day long.

I used to curl my eyelashes everyday, and I was very skeptical of this "magic" mascara. It really does work! It doesn't clp and curls my lashes making my eyes look more open. It's great.

At $31 CDN it pretty expensive but its the best formulation I've tried. Doesn't flake or get crispy. My new HG mascara, no more DIOR Show for me.

best mascara i have ever used this mascara makes my eyelashes look like i have fake lashes on! stays forever and curls your lashes so you don't even need to use a curler I also put over top bad gal to make them even bigger

I love this mascara. I was reluctant to try it at first, because I did not like the They're Real mascara from Benefit and I thought this would be catering to the same people. But I received a sample and fell in love. I instantly went out and bought a full size out of fear of running out. It is the only mascara I will use without my eyelash curler because it gives it some lift.