Great concept

I love this idea of this product, which is the main reason I bought it. It saves time because I don't have much of it, and it just goes on smoothly. It fades out really nicely so despite the full colour not staying on, at least it fades to a lighter version and it's not patchy

Good, but not a huge fan

I liked this lipstick, in that it applied very easily, and in addition lasted. The colour was very pigmented as well.
The thing I did not like too much was the specific colour, it was too pink for me, and in addition did not go well with my skin tone.
Also, it had a chemically smell, at least I found that it did, and did not sit well with me for that reason.
Other than that, I do not down this product because it is much higher end that many products out there, and fits well with the Benefit brand image.

Bonne idée de produit

Je trouve que le concept du produit avec ses deux couleurs est une bonne idée, j'aime beaucoup la mode du dégrader sur les lèvres. Par contre, quand on l'applique sur les lèvres, les deux couleurs ont tendance à se mélanger et au final, il n'y a pas de dégradé, du moins pour moi. Aussi, la tenue du produit est plutôt bonne, mais il y a des transfère ce qui n'est donc pas exceptionnel pour le prix du produit.

J'apprécie donc le rouge à lèvre que j'ai, mais je ne pense pas m'en racheter un autre.

A little gimicky and takes a few tries to master application

I was sent a free sample of this through a promotion that Benefit was having. I do love the colour, and it's very suiting on those with a fair complexion. However, the duo-toned concept of it all is a little bit gimicky. It's a little tricky to master application because you have to flip over the lipstick to line your bottom lip with the darker shade. And if you're like me and not very skilled with lining your lips, you'll find that the darker shade will dwindle faster than the lighter shade. However, if you can master application the lipstick itself is a lovely formula. It lasts for several hours, applies smoothly, and doesn't dry up or flake away throughout the day.

So I don't really wear lipstick a lot... But I recieved this as a free sample and I tried it a Few times... Mine was like a peach colour.. It wasnt bad but wasn't my favourite either

Benefit sent me a sample of this and I am in shock ! I'm not much of a lipstick girl in general and the idea of combining the liner and the lipstick seemed more difficult to use. But I was proven so wrong because this made using lipstick so much easier ! This SERIOUSLY plumps your lips up so much and now I don't have to deal with trying to draw the perfect shape for my lips - this does it all for me !

I received a sample of the Benefit Liner Lipstick. I thought it was a really cool idea. It was easy to apply to the top lip but not too successful for the bottom. I found the lipstick very drying and didn't like the feel of it on my lips. Not as good as I thought this product would be.

I received this lip liner/lipstick in the mail opend it and put it on, halfto say its soo much easier than tracing your lips with a liner stick then putting the lipstick on, its quicker and just all around better I love it.

I received this lovely lipstick through my Premium membership and must say it goes only easily and makes my lips look great. It's a lipstick and liner all in one! Perfect! The colour I received was Pink Thrills Beyond Sexy Lipstick and Liner all in one. Unfortunately it was a little too pink for me but it was perfect for my best friend. She loved it too. I will definitely buy this product just in a different colour.

J'ai recu 2 échantillons de Benefit They're Real lipstick et j'ai été vraiment impressionnée. Avec se nouveau rouge à levre avec "crayon" contour intégré en un seul geste facile nous avons un look parfait qui ne dépassera pas du contour de vos levres a mesure que la journée avance. Le produit est hydratant et durable. Voici mon avis sur les couleurs que j'ai recus.
Lusty Rose: définitivement ma couleur préféré. N'est pas trop foncé pour aller avec mon teint pale et la couleur est d'un rose profond.
Pink Thrills: une couleur plus marqué, qui tend vers le rouge et est tres riche. Un peu trop foncé a mon gout.
Trouver votre couleur en vaudra vraiment la peine.