Took me a few tries to get used to this mascara! I really liked the way it worked after about 2 or 3 times. Honestly im like that with every mascara. It takes time to get used to it!

I was watching greys anatomy last night (the part were derek died) and god bless i cried my eyes out and this mascara stayed on. No stains on my pillow. I cried so much and woke up this morning and the mascara was still on!

Definitely a very very waterproof mascara. I love the way it makes my lashes longer!! I adore the Benefit line so much. I don't really need more volume in my lashes so this product is for me.

I truly believe that Benefit Mascaras are by far the best mascaras and I love that They're Real also comes in Blue which is so fun! Mascara is something I splurge on because the product will last you like 6 months anyway! I get such great length, volume and definition out of Benefit They're Real.

This is a nice mascara but not one of my favourites. I love receiving it free, I'm more likely to use it up and it does the job in the meantime until I find my favourite, but it definitely is not the best or would not purchase on my own time. Not thick enough for me but it does the job. Not entirely fond of the finish once its dry

The wand on this mascara is amazing. On all other mascaras, the wands end up being covered in product and the bristles are not even recognizable. For this mascara, once you take out the wand, the excess product gets wipes off through the tight opening and you are left with a very defined brush that helps apply the mascara nicely on your eyelashes with no clumping at all!

This mascara is definitely waterproof so I'll give it that; however, aside from that, there isnt much else to write about. I was not a fan of how gunky this made my lashes feel, as well, i found this mascara to really weigh down my lashes. Overall, this was not a mascara that I would purchase again.

The only mascara that will curl my eyelashes and I've tried anything from drugstore to boutique brands and still nothing! and this is even after using a curler. With the benefit mascara, I still use a curler but at least they curl! It stays on forever and it's truly waterproof. Really have to give it a good rub with eye makeup remover to come off!

My HG. The moment I tried it I knew we'll be together, forever. I am ultimately impressed and lost for words when i compared my eyes with and without it. Dont know what kind of sorcery is in there but 99.9% of me looks more awake and fab. No need for falsies, just build up the coats and viola, ultra sexy lashes. Ive always loved benefit Cosmetics but this is my most favorite product from them. It holds my lashes well. I just wish its waterproof and smudge-proof, coulve been purrfect.

This quickly became my go-to mascara. The brush separates lashes perfectly while the formula adds volume and length to lashes. I never have a problem with clumping and the mascara stays put until I want to remove it.