I like this mascara but the price is a little high for something you have to change frequently. It actually makes my eyelashes look like I have falsies on. I personably love it but the formula makes my eyes water if I forget to take my makeup off while I sleep which is more my problem and I've only heard of it happening to me so overall it's good just a bit pricey

This mascara is very good in my opinion. I have very short and straight eye lashes. This mascara makes my eye appear bigger and the eyelashes are definitely thicker and curlier. However, it doesn't last me all day. I usually get smudge mark under my eye in the evening.

I really enjoy this Mascara! Not exactly thrilled on the price, but the quality is really good. I find my lashes are longer and thicker after using this product. I will keep using this product!

I'm someone who LOVES mascara, I cannot leave the house without it; I usually buy drugstore mascaras because part of me can't fathom paying upwards of 20-30$ for a mascara that literally is only good for about 1 month or so. I got Benefit Cosmetics They're Real! Mascara for christmas and have been using it every day since, and I LOVE it! It took me a few days to get used to the application because it can get clumpy fast, but if you work slowly and in small strokes, you can achieve a beautiful look that makes your lashes look super long! Some people think it's hard to remove, but I use an eye makeup remover from the body shop and it takes it off just fine.

My only qualm is the price!!! It's just so expensive, you can buy the small sample sizes for I believe $12, which is decent considering a small sample lasts you about a month, but i highly recommend this product if you buy the sample size so you can decide for yourself. It works well, but I wouldn't say it's better than my favourite drugstore mascara which is the Rimmel London Lash Accelerator Endless.

This is my go to mascara it adds major length and volume without any clumps! its perfect for the every day look or pair it with eyeliner for a night time look. Although it is pricey, it is worth every penny!

Pricey, but in my opinion, worth it! Really makes your eyes pop! Lengthens sooo much. I don't find smudging to be and issue or flaking. I love this and will definitely buy it again.

I finally decided to try this mascara by Benefit called they're real and it's an amazing product. Not only does it go on smoothly without clumping, it doesn't smudge and adds remarkable length to my eyelashes. I love how the jet black colour brings out my eyes. Thanks #Benefit for such a product worth buying.

I just recently purchased and tried this mascara out. I own just the black one (there is coloured ones now brown, and blue) I was overall impressed by the quality of it compared to some mascaras that I have tried in the past. It is really volumizing like it says, the only thing I dont like about this mascara is that the formula itself is really sticky and almost like waterproof mascara. The only thing is that it isnt waterproof, it smudges when wet but it sticks to your eyelashes like glue. Now some people might be into that but Im not so crazy about that! Even using a really good makeup remover, its a pain to remove. Overall I would recommend as a Mascara to anyone that prefers waterproof and needs it to stay put for hours and hours.

I really love the benefit cosmetic products. This mascara is really good! It glides on really easily and there's no clumps.

I love using this mascara when I really want my eyes to pop! The hard bristles of the wand allow for maximum separation, while it makes the base of my lashes super dark. The only complaint I have about this mascara is that it has the tendency to smudge under my eyes which is sad :(