The color was really black and the formula wasnt as thick as i would like it. After i curled my eyelash i find my eyelashes drooped down a little and i had to recurl it. Overall the quality was okay. And the packaging was pretty neat rather than regular tubes.

I'm asian and it's sometimes difficult to find that perfect mascara that will thicken your lashes and not smudge every time you blink. This mascara is definitely working for me. I got hooked after getting a sample from Sephora, now I haven't used a another mascara since. It's definitely worth every penny and I would highly recommend giving it a try.

an awesome mascara thats for sure! it has a ball on the end to get the corner and for bottom lashes. Your lashes will really stand out with this mascara!

I really liked the effect of this mascara, but my only issue was that it tended to give me raccoon eyes by the end of the day.

All my friends adore this product, so I figured I'd give it a try. Honestly, I'm not impressed - but I had high standards going in. I like it, it's a good mascara.. I just don't think it's worth the price. I don't notice a huge difference between benefit they're real and the typical drugstore mascara.

This is the ONLY mascara I ever use. I had short little lashes, but with a coat or two of They're Real, people legitimately have asked if I have eyelash extensions. They add so much length without being clumpy at all! The price point is a bit expensive, but I swear it's worth it if you have short lashes that need a lot of oomph!

This is a great mascara that I purchased from Sephora. I find it really helps lengthen and curl my lashes. It is a bit pricey at almost 30$ a tube, but it is definitely worth the price. I have long lashes, but they're relatively straight. I like how this mascara allows my lashes to have a decent curl. I will definitely repurchase this item.

I got a sample of this mascara a few years ago and it quickly became my favourite. It's a little pricey but it does the job really well. My eyelashes always look full and big. With most drug store mascaras I don't get that close to false eyelash look but with They're real I always do! The only problem I have with it is it does clump slightly more than I would like and it is also a little difficult to get off. The cons aren't important enough that I would stop using it though.

This was the first Benefit product I tried, and it was because of a Sephora birthday gift! I absolutely love thsi mascara and it was the first one that didn't leave my lashes clumped together.

I really had big hopes for this mascara. Although my lashes did look pretty good I was not impressed how much this product clumped up on the second coat. And I apply thin coats. I have received better results from average drugstore mascaras. This one is just not worth the hype for me.