You get what you pay for with these, at least in my opinion.
They are extremely dry and are almost impossible to apply. The only way I get any color at all with these, is to run it under a flame for a minute or so until it warms up. Then it does draw/line my eyes, but the color is so light, it looks like I have worn it all day and its faded. I don't care for this line of liners, I don't have any luck with them even though others rave about them, perhaps it's my climate or lack of patience.

This product is decent, it does the job, but if you're looking for a more professional look, I would definitely go for a liquid liner or something similar.

A bit of a flop for me i'm afraid. Wen't on nice a smooth but smudged instantly, ran, and was not flattering at all. The price was great, but that's the only nice thing I have to say about this eye liner.

Eh, I cant say Im a fan. Its definitely very cheap, but it smudges and does not go on smoothly. It is also not waterproof...will not recommend.