This has to be my favourite out of the three flavours. It has a hint of french vanilla and banana which wasn't strong, but just enough to taste the flavour. I'm afraid it'll finish faster than I expected -- I will definitely buy this package soon! The best part: I like the little bits of crumbs in the banana flavoured ice cream.

I would have to say that bananas are one of my favourite fruit, so I was really curious and interested to see if this ice cream flavour would deliver. While I do not like Banana Cream Pie, the Breyers Ice cream was amazing. The banana flavour was subtle and natural and I also liked the graham cracker bits in it. The texture of this ice cream was really fluffy and smooth and creamy, definitely worth trying.

I have to admit, like many others, I was apprehensive about this flavour! But, also very curious! Bryers Double Chrun Banana Cream Pie Ice Cream was delicious! The banana taste was not too over powering and it wasn't too sweet either. I really liked the bits of "crust" in the ice cream. The texture was smooth and creamy, the way ice cream should be!

An excellent alternative to boring vanilla or chocolate!

I was a bit hesitant in trying this flavour even though I enjoy banana-flavoured things, I adore banana-flavoured popsicles and liked the banana-flavoured medicine that I had to take once as a child. For some reason though, Banana Cream Pie just seemed kind of odd for an ice cream flavour. I am glad that I got over my aversion to the idea as this flavour tasted really good! It was a nice smooth texture and I also liked how there was a ribbon of the pie crust running throughout the ice cream, it added a nice pop of flavour. The banana flavour itself was nice and refreshing, though I wish the flavour was a bit stronger, it was a bit too mild in intensity to me. Definitely a yummy and unique flavour and I will buy again for sure!

I have to say, this one for me was definitely my least favourite of the the 3 flavours that I got to try with the Product Review Club. I am not a fan of banana flavoured products especially banana flavoured candy and cough syrup. It just has this weird fake banana taste normally - not at all like what a real banana tastes like.

With that being said, Breyers Banana Cream Pie has certainly exceeded my expectations. While I won't claim to say that I love this flavour or would buy it again, I will say that it was much more pleasant that I expected. For one thing, it tasted like REAL banana (not like the cough syrup flavour stuff). So if you like banana products you should love this one. I also liked that this had a crunch to it. I guess that would be the crust of the pie. One thing I didn't really like though was that I thought this was supposed to be extra creamy. I didn't find it to be as creamy as other Breyers Extra Churned flavours. I thought there was more of a milk solids taste to it.

To be sure, this was definitely better than I expected and if I liked banana products I would absolutely buy it again.

I was very excited to be chosen as one of the reviewers for the 3 new Breyers ice cream flavours. The ice cream party kit was very well presented, with 3 small bowls and 3 spoons to share the wonderful goodness with friends.

Double Churn Banana Cream Pie was the first flavour we tried. It's funny how many reviewers mentioned the dreaded childhood banana-flavoured medicine; that's exactly what I was thinking about when we were scooping out the ice cream! I'm not a fan of banana-flavoured anything at all. However, I was pleasantly surprised. The creamy texture is balanced very nicely with the graham cracker crust bits. The banana flavour is so subtle that if I hadn't known, I don't think I would have guessed it was banana. It's not overly sweet, which makes it a pleasure to eat.

The price is perhaps a little high, as others have mentioned, and I don't think I would go out of my way to buy this flavour, but I'm glad I got the opportunity to try it.

The first thing I notice was how creamy and smooth this ice cream was, it was wonderful. I was a little worried that I would not like it, as I am not a very big fan of bananas. There was a great banana flavour and a hint of vanilla. The crunchy pie pieces are great and compliment the flavour very nicely. This is not my favourite of the three but it is defenatly worth recomending to anyone who wants to try a new flavour or banana cream pie lovers.

this ice cream is creamy and smooth just like the other double churn ice cream from breyers.
i have never tried a banana flavored ice cream before but to my surprise i enjoyed it. it had a light sweet banana flavor that was very rich and creamy. if you have never tried banana flavored ice cream this is the one to try! (:

I was a bit wary of the Banana Cream Pie only because in the past, other banana flavoured frozen desserts have had such overpowering faux banana flavours, that they resemble that banana-flavoured medicine I used to have as a kid. But this was quite different. Along with my ensemble of ice-cream samplers, we dug in to a rich creamy ice cream with a delicious crunch of graham crackers swirled throughout. The flavour was just the right amount of banana and, complimented by the graham cracker, it actually tasted like Banana Cream Pie! At the actual tasting, this flavour was an instant hit despite many of us agreeing we may not have reached out for it while grocery shopping had we not just tasted it. It definitely hit both the ice cream spot and the dessert craving - you don't need to side it with anything BUT it goes nicely with the Velvet Dark Chocolate.

My disclaimer is that I don't like banana ice cream because of my fear of that terrible banana taste from medicine when I was a kid!

BUT - this was pretty darn good, I will admit.

I had my family try it out as well and they were on board - creamy, not too strong on the banana flavour, and generally good.

It won't be my first choice, but it's a fun alternative to serve up at a party!