Ok, but not great

I received 2 100% Natural Origin Defining Eyeliner in the shades "Mulberry" and "Onyx" for free in exchange for my honest opinion.

I really liked both of these colours, especially the Mulberry, as it is a beautiful shade of purple.  They were fairly pigmented, but did not last long on the waterline. 

These liners glided smoothly when testing them on my hand, but were a little less smooth when applying to my eyelids.  They worked better in the waterline but still required a second pass. 

I like that they contain Jojoba oil and Shea Butter, which helps to nourish my lashes to keep them healthy.  I also really like that they are retractable. 

Overall, they are decent liners for everyday looks, but might not be suitable for more dramatic looks.