Honestly, this is probably the worst mascara I've ever used - and I've tried a lot! This was my first Clinique product, and I'm sad to say that it did not work for me at all. Once I opened the mascara and looked at the wand, I knew it was going to be bad. The mascara clumped in large clumps all over the wand, and when applied, clumps really, really bad. It is the worst clumping mascara I've ever used.

I felt like it was pretty good in terms of how waterproof it was. We went to a water park and it held up fairly well, although a little came off under my eyes, which isn't good. I don't usually buy waterproof mascaras, but I bought it because I knew I was going to be in the water a lot, and wanted to look okay.

Maybe I just got a bad batch or something, but this stuff is really bad. I do not recommend it!