I do love Clinique products. They have reliable formulas and I have never had any problems with Clinique on my skin. I bought the Clinique Lid Pop in Petal Pop which is shimmering pink colour in the container. It is a buttery consistency but the colour pay off wasn't as good as I had hoped for. The colour is very very light. I also tried using white eyeshadow as a base but it didn't help. I will still use this as a bit of shimmer for the inner corners of my eyes. I haven't tried the other colours but I have seen good reviews for them especially Vanilla Pop. I'm on the fence about this colour but I do like the formula.