Amazing

I used this for years and liked it a lot. It twists up so you don't have to worry about sharpening it. It lasts a while, is pigmented and creamy so it glides on nice and is very black. It has a thin tip so it's great for precision lining but as you use it it does flatten a bit, not enough to make it unusable though if you want thin lines. I have brown eyes and this would help accentuate them and brighten them. It doesn't melt off through the day and stays pretty well on my oily lids. I use it to line my waterline and it did a pretty good job of staying put. Sometimes it would make my eyes water though but that was usually if I had been using it for many months and only on my lower lash line. I've bought this product many times and will continue as an alternative to liquid liner. Also, it comes off very easily with makeup remover or face wash.