Cover Girl Extremely Gentle Softliner is water-resistant, smudge-resistant, long wearing and safe for contact wearers. It is hard to find but worth it once you do. It goes on easily and stays on until you remove it with make-up remover. It is gentle on the eyes for those with sensitive eyes. 8 ml sells for $14.99, comes in Black and Blackbrown. I really love this eyeliner!