i was disapointed with this mascara. i usually love covergirl mascaras but this one just didnt cut it
i got the waterproof in blackest black. i found that the formula made the curl fall out of my eyelashes and it really isnt water proof after a few hours of wear i found that i either had flakes under my eyes or that if i touch my eye the mascara was falling off

If you are looking for a cheaper version of benefit's they're real, this is it! It separates every lash and gives it an even coat. You get a volumized look with little to no clumping. The only downside to this mascara is that the formula dried pretty hard and could potentially break off a few lashes here and there.

Unfortunately, not my favourite. I don't know if it's because of the brush/formula or because I have long eyelashes but it seems to go on quite spiky! The brush seems sharp and it does flake if you use more than 1 coat.

I tried this one because I like the idea of nourishing my lashes with natural ingredients. I do find that it goes on a bit clumpier than my usual brand, the cult classic Maybelline a Great Lash, and it lacks some coverage. Works ok but not on my 'must have' list.

I was excited about this product as I had a coupon on Checkout 51 also .
At first , when I put the mascara on - I literally had to put about 5-6 coats on to even see a full effect. I have long eyelashes also.
Half way during the day , I noticed that the mascara was leaving prints on the top of my eyes! This has never happened with any other mascara before.

This mascara was meh. The wand was decent enough in combing, separating and removing clumps. The product on the other hand was not as great as I had hoped. The mascara was not as thickening as I wanted and it did not lengthen my lashes. On the makeup removal from this mascara lasts all day and removes easily with a removal wipe.

I did not find this product effective.

After seeing the Katy Perry commercial, I figured I would give the product a try, and overall I found it to be a average mascara. The rubber tipped application wand did a great job of applying the product evenly and minimized clumping really well. I found my lashed got wonderful length and separation but very little volume due too the mascaras almost watery consistency. It has great buildability once totally dry, but took forever to get any substantial volume. I am not sure if I would purchase again.