I'm disappointed in this eyeliner. I bought it because it had great reviews, and promised to be completely smudge proof. While it does go on smooth, and has fairly good staying power, it is definitely NOT smudge proof. I like how it looks, and it does stay on much better than quite a few other eyeliners I've tried, but I probably won't be buying it again.

I paid $6.99 for this which is a little pricey but it did work well for a little while. Than it started to crack off and after about two weeks all of the liner stick was cracked off and there was none left to twist up. So disappointing.

I bought this product in "Cocoa Ink (260)". Doesnt smudge easily, which can make it hard to blend, but stays on all day. The color is nice and goes well with a lot of my makeup, as I wear a lot of natural tones. My only complaint is that, it doesnt go on very smoothly. It catches my lid and can make it difficult to create a nice, even line. Does great along my water lines though! Goes on more smoothly there or on top of eyeshadow.

Product can become chalky quickly but other than that worth the money!