I was excited to try this product. It was a great price for what it offered and CoverGirl has a great reputation. The paddle end for the eyeliner is difficult to get use to, but once you do it works well. The product was great until about two weeks later and it was mostly dried out. I was very disappointed. Ladies, my advice is save your money and buy yourself some Benefit. It's going to last longer and will go on like a dream!

I wear liquid eyeliner every time I wear make-up - it is a regular part of my make-up routine - I have been doing so since I was 13. And so, I feel like I am fairly well versed when it comes to the realm of liquid liners. Right off the bat, I will say that I absolutely LOVE the shade of blue on this liner! It is like a royal blue with a nice matte finish - I have been really loving the combination of the sapphire liner with a nice gold eyeshadow. The consistency of the liner itself is nice - it's not overly wet or dry - it doesn't take too long for the liner to dry, which is nice. I did do a smudge test on the back of my hand, and it did rub off a bit. However, I had no such problems on my eyes - the liner lasted the entire day. It glided smoothly over my other eye make-up (i.e. primer and eyeshadows). I do like the fact that the liner comes in a pen format - it is a lot easier to control while trying to draw a line. With that said, however, I am honestly not a huge fan of the new "paddle" tip. I wish the felt tip was finer/thinner! Even the thinnest part of the tip is quite thick, making it a little difficult to really control the thickness of the line you draw. Also, because the paddle tip is rounded. I feel like when I do use the wider side, I can't get a nice sharp edge on my liner - it's much more rounded. So, I have to go back in with the finer tip to sharpen up the edges. I feel like it will take a little getting used to the tip - so, with practice I might actually come to appreciate the new tip. However, my first few impressions have left me wishing the tip was smaller. I do worry that the felt tip might dry up quickly, but so far, it has remained moist.

I received this product through my job to give it a test today and was very disappointed in it. The application was good as it was nice, crisp black and the ability to turn to what ever thickness was handy. But all day it was sticky and stuck to my eyelids getting smudged all over. I even tried setting it with a powder shadow to try to dry it up and it was just awful. I looked like a raccoon at work all day no matter what I did to fix it. It had such a tacky texture that refused to set...not impressed.