I found this liner thin and difficult to apply. I had difficulties using it with eye shadows, the color changes depending on your shadow. Definitely do not intend on purchasing again.

Pretty dissapointed with this product. It dried out before I could get a couple uses in. From the time i purchased the product till when it dried out probably a month in. Quality of the liquid liner was okay. I had the blackest black. Colour came out alright, product did smudge a little.

Hmmm....I'm still on the fence with this liner. I've been looking for a new one to replace a discontinued brand I have been using for years. So far I've noticed that the never seems to be enough product on the tip of the applicator. Wearability is good, but I have noticed if I don't use a little shadow tot set it, it fades. I've only used the product a handful of times, so I'll keep on it for a few more wears to see if I may repurchase.

After trying this liner for a day I realized it was not for me. The colour was perfect but the felt tip would rub off the liner that was already applied to my line. I found that I constantly needed to shake the liner if I wanted a good amount of liner. The price is good, but I'd much rather the CoverGirl pencil liner than the felt tip.

Not my favourite liner. I received this one for free from CoverGirl and though it has some redeeming qualities, the formula just didn't make the cut for me. The felt tip application/marker style is easy to use, but I do wish it was a little thinner and more fine. The formular dries quickly but then when you go over a line, it basically just rubs off and you're left with a bit of a chunky mess on your hands. I actually had to go over this with another liner to get the black, defined line that I wanted. I find that liners are easier to use when its a longer handle as well, this is too short and stumpy to use. It isn't a bad price, but it wouldn't be my first pick in the drugstore.