I found this to be a bit clumpy and thick. Whenever I got a fresh tube it would need to be scraped off the applicator for the first few months to get it thin enough to not clump up. It stayed on well and didn't smudge but I ultimately switched to something lighter with better lengthening results. If you're looking for a thick looking lash this is your product, if you want something soft and natural go skip this one.

Just bought this couple weeks ago cause I was going on vacation and didn't want to take my regular Defincils with me and I was amazed at the comparison

One of my all time best affordable drug store mascara ever! It does it job as well as lasting throughout the day! I'd usually get the waterproof one and it works wonders!

Cover Girl is a fairly good product name and I purchase a lot of their products.This is one of thee best Mascara's on the market because ,it doesn't clump, and that is the very first thing I look for in a a Mascara.Some Mascaras when you use them a couple of time,they tend to get all thick and clumpy.Cover Girl Mascara In Blackest Black is my favorite.I think it lasts longer than most mascaras do also you can get them in many other shades to suite your hair colour or whatever.I think the price is gone down a bit because the last time I purchased it,it was like about a couple dollars cheaper.I recommend this product,it is a good eye Mascara.

I decided to buy some new cover girl mascara to try it , in the orange tube (water proof) I hate it , it makes my eyelashes so heavy and straight .. Also extremely hard to get off

I am a redhead and my lashes are blond - invisible. So I need a good mascara to show that I do have eyelashes. So this mascara is one good buy. It coats each lash very well. I use black so the lashes show up more. A very good buy!

I use this mascara all the time. I don't like paying to much for a product and this is definitely within the budget. It creates black and dramatic lashes.

This is the only mascara my daughter will wear. Puts on easy and lasts. One concern is that if it is expired it has caused her eyes to go red almost like an allergy.

This is my favorite mascara! I have been using it for years. It works better for me than lots of high price mascara and is much more affordable. It doesn't clump and makes my lashes full and long

This is my daily use mascara I find it does not clump up it goes on nice and evenly. Makes your eyelashes appear fuller, I find it makes your eyes just pop leaving your lashes looking natural.