My go to

Always buy this mascara. I like how it makes my lashes longer and full. However, I find it to be expensive for the amount of time it lasts. I wish it lasted longer. It does clump up. I say it’s my go to because it’s what I know and is the beat of the kinda I have tried.

Pass on this one

Cover girl mascara is my go to drugstore choice. I was super disappointed with this product. Clumps, dries out super fast, and wasn’t a fan of the brush. Threw it out shortly after I got it as it wasn’t working for me.

I tried this product and was very disappointed. I tried to clean my eyelashes before going to bed one night and my eyelashes were falling. I used baby oil and gently rubbed to be able to remove it. Not sure why, but will definitely will not buy Covergirl again. Will stick with other brands that I had no problem with.

This is a great product to put on but it still causes smudging after an hour or so. It is ok at maintaining curl for my stick straight lashes, however, smudging is my major concern. Although waterproof, it still causes raccoon eyes. I would not repurchase unless you don't have smudging problems. As a mascara, it is great at volume and length!

It's not that waterproof, afte 20 min of pool start to get messy

Added lots of volume and was easy to apply

Nothing special...wouldn't really recommend it..but if u want something cheap and waterproof then this is fine although it's nothing special

Found this product clumped alot

I like really big lashes, and this product just doesn't deliver for me. The formula is thin and the bristles on the wand are too short. I find it wears off and I have to reapply it by lunch. No thanks.

This product is easy to use but it must be applied a couple of time to get the best coverage