This is creamy and easily glides along the skin. It self sharpens as you twist the product. I wish it was a more finer point. I applied it on my water lines and above the lash line. This holds all day above the lash line. However, this doesn't last all day on the water lines. About 4 hours into wearing the eyeliner, it was wearing off so I had to touch up. I did not use the smudger tip because I never smudge my eyeliner so I can't give you an opinion on that other than it's a soft sponge. This is an okay eye liner, but I've had better.

I really did not like this eyeliner. I always buy self-sharpening eyeliners, but hadn't tried this brand before. The price was good, so I thought I would give it a shot. I'm pretty disappointed in it. Compared to similar products, this product gets used up WAY too fast - it was all gone in under a month, and I don't even use it every day. I bought it in black, and it was definitely not a true black - every time I tried to smudge it, it looked like I was wearing bright blue! I will not be buying this product again.