This mascara for me was terrible all around and I've never used the regular Super Sizer Mascara. If you had great lashes to begin with, then you'd probably love this, but I don't which is why I look for mascara like this. I want to add volume and make my lashes noticeable. Well this made my few sparse lashes clump, that's the only way I got volume... not a good look. Then it was ridiculously hard to get it off my lashes, even after using waterproof makeup remover.

All I have to say is this is not the best Mascara. I was at the movies and my eyes started to well up at a particular point in the movie. While wiping the tears, I noticed black on my hands. This mascara should not have run after only a few tears. I truly would not recommend this mascara. I am definitely disappointed.