Mixed Feelings Here

This mascara is waterproof. That is no lie. It's TOO waterproof. I have to triple cleanse to remove most of it. It makes my eyelashes so stiff they hurt. BUT it stays put, even through a shower. It holds a curl. It's just too much. I actually bought this one by mistake. I didn't realize that there was a non waterproof and waterproof version. I liked the regular version. All of the pluses of this mascara with none of the pain.

This is one of my all time favorite mascaras. It applies beautifully, does not clump or smudge and is a rich black. I love the applicator brush on this mascara too

I have love-hate relationship with this mascara! I don't know why some days when I open it is dry and sometimes not, but honestly my lashes last all day with this mascara!

It runs very smoothly on you laches and makes them more bigger. I don't like how there's a lot of tiny pieces of mascara every were when I put some on.

I really really like this mascara. I actually feel like it noticeably lengthens my eyelashes and makes them super long! It did take many applications to get the desired length I was looking for though. It is also super black in colour which is totally my style. I think this may become my regular mascara.

I really like the brush on this mascara because I find that it's the type that helps eliminate clumping. The one bad thing about this mascara is that if you're looking for volume, this is not the mascara for you. What this mascara is wonderful for is length. For people with thick lashes that just want longer ones, this is perfect. I'm the opposite; I have long lashes and want volume. However, sometimes I like this type of mascara if I want noticeable lashes without it looking like I'm wearing false lashes. My one problem with this mascara is that it's basically the same brush as Julep's Length Matters mascara, which I think is much better quality and it gives more volume along with the length. As well, this Covergirl mascara claims to be waterproof, but I don't think it really holds up to that. All in all, it's fairly decent for a drugstore mascara.

very disappointed in this mascara. it does volumize a a bit but it is very clumpy