Very Waterproof formula!

I can confirm that this is a very good waterproof mascara. Broke down crying at work today several times and it didn’t budge. Can be a little difficult to remove at the end of the day because of how effective it is, so invest in a good makeup remover. The Super Sizer mascara that I love as my go to but with a perfected waterproof formula.

Mixed Feelings Here

This mascara is waterproof. That is no lie. It's TOO waterproof. I have to triple cleanse to remove most of it. It makes my eyelashes so stiff they hurt. BUT it stays put, even through a shower. It holds a curl. It's just too much. I actually bought this one by mistake. I didn't realize that there was a non waterproof and waterproof version. I liked the regular version. All of the pluses of this mascara with none of the pain.

This is one of my all time favorite mascaras. It applies beautifully, does not clump or smudge and is a rich black. I love the applicator brush on this mascara too

The brush in mine may have been defective - the bristles were so short that they were barely there, and as a result, too much mascara got on my lashes when I tried to use it. Really disappointed that this didn't work for me, as I've heard that it does amazing things for small/skimpy lashes. I might re-buy another one to see if the brush is the same. The formula seems OK, just need a good brush to go along with it!

This mascara is terrible! When the brush isn't making my eyelashes stick together, the mascara is leaving clumps. After a while, the mascara flakes all over your face. Definitely never again.

I have to say I haven't used much in the ways of cheaper make up in a long time. I was in a drug store the other day and ended up buying 3 different ones because they were all roughly 5 dollars.

I love this though it has a strange brush, the only thing I didn't like was the brush was hard to do bottom lashes. I feel like this one did better at length then thickness.

I am usually not a CoverGirl fan, however, I decided to take the plunge with this mascara and can say that I am very pleased I did. For the first time in years, I can honestly say that this mascara has changed my long live negative perspective of CoverGirl products.

When they say waterproof, they mean it. I had applied this mascara in the a.m. and by that evening, even with a waterproof makeup remover, I had trouble removing it. It is sweat and tear proof and does wonders for your lashes. It gives length and volume for beautiful full lashes. A definite must have for your glamour looks or just a popping eye look with a natural look.

First I want to say I wear a lot of eye make up, I love the dramatic look, like black eyeliner, smoky eyes and the long dramatic lashes but unfortunately do not naturally have much for lashes so I often wear falsies....with this Mascara I don't need anything else not even eyeshadow this Mascara is AMAZING and I will buy if for as long as I am able.

I love this Mascara so much. I have many other mascaras in my makeup drawer but I keep coming back to this one. It curls, holds the curl, waterproof, lengthens and is CLUMP-FREE! I love this mascara so much, i've purchased it twice now and will go back for more! Also, its very worth the price. At my local store it costs about $6-7 dollars, which is very reasonable. This is an awesome mascara! The effectiveness multiplies if you curl before you apply, and re-curl after applying. That is how I apply this product and I believe this way works the best. I know some people are skeptical of curling after mascara application but its ok for me :P. Great job Covergirl!

I first tried this mascara as part of the Limited Edition Star Wars line, and I was thrilled that it is a regular CoverGirl product, too! This mascara adds volume and length, is truly waterproof, and comes off easily with makeup remover! I love this mascara!