For the first month of using this mascara, it worked well - long lashes with some volume and a curl. There was minimal clumping. It wore all day - and some waterproof properties, even though it was never mentioned on the package. The price was excellent too.

Then it dried out and became unusable after a month. No amount of eye drops, shaking or heating it up could revive it.

It is great in a pinch. If frequent replacement is okay, this would be a decent option for tight budgets.