Had a sample and it's just the same as drugstore black liners. Save some money and get the NYC one which is like 3$ in Canada, and even cheaper in USA.

Save your money...I was so excited to get this home to try.....very disappointed. When you apply this liner it sometimes comes out too quickly or not enough. The line can be faint......I have been trying this for a month...I wear makeup almost everyday.....I refuse to throw it away because it was 43.00 plus tax.....I have never paid that much for an eyeliner and probably never would again....I have use sephora and Arbonne liquid eyeliner and I was happier with them...Very disappointed.....