Not so smudge-resistant on my eyes

I hadn't tried any products from this brand previously but their first impression unfortunately wasn't a great one for me.

I gave this eyeliner a try without using any kind of primer on the lid first since it was supposedly smudge resistant. Not the case for me - it honestly all transferred to my upper lid area within a couple of hours of normal wear indoors. Now just as a caveat to you readers out there, I do have quite oily skin so I can be tricky with these kinds of kohl liners. I don't normally buy them but since this one was a gift I gave it a try anyways.

I will say that the application part was quite nice and easy. The pencil is very pigmented and creamy when it applies. Not too much tugging at the lid or poking to try to get a nice cat-eye. If you have drier skin this may work for you. The pencil comes with a little smudger on one end you can use to blend out your smoky eye.