First of all, the price is unbeatable! $3 and it's worth every penny. It's very creamy, smooth, super pigmented, not too heavy. It's nowhere near waterproof or smudgeproof, but you can't beat it for the price!

I hate dragging a pencil over my eyelid, so cream eyeliners are my preference. Love the e.l.f. ones for the value and there's a ton in the little pot. The small brush that comes with the product works well, although it's pretty tiny. I prefer a longer brush most of the time.

Doesn't last as long as a pencil liner, but with a bit of setting does the job well.

I bought this product in hopes to transition from a pencil liner to a cream eyeliner. Overall, it is good for the price, although difficult to apply with the provided brush. I am hoping with the purchase of a new eyeliner brush this will be a better product for me.

My favourite eyeliner hands down. I love to use black for winged liner and coffee for my brows (try it, it will shock you) i love this stuff i just wish it was easier to access in canada :(

I love this eyeliner ! It's amazing. It going on dark the first time and dosent smudge. will probably need your own brush because the one it comes with isn't very good and it's short and hard to use. I would 100% recommend this.

Loved this eyeliner, it applied so smoothly and easily. It was perfectly bold and didn't fade

Love using this product, I find it lasts and it doesn't come off easy if you happen to wipe it. It's super easy to clean and put on and very smooth.

This is probably the best eyeliner I have ever used before. It goes on and stays on smooth. It is easily seen and easy to maneuver. The price is way less than any other brand by far.

When I first bought these (Turquoise and dark purple) I was in love, the colour was so vibrant and they went on really easily with the little brush they came with. However, they lasted about a week before they dried up completely and fell right out of the jar. I know they're not expensive, but I just expected them to last way longer than they did.

Best liner I've ever used. I wouldn't use the brush that it came with though, but aside from that, this is my go-to gel liner. Perfect for creating thin or bold lines and very durable. Plus the price is astounding!