This lipliner pencil (bitter) is great. It is much shorter than other lipliner pencils, but for $1USD i can't really complain. It also comes with a sharpener. Its a very versatile pink red color, which blends into berry lipsticks and red lipsticks very well. The staying power for this lipliner isn't great, but it does it's job well for $1. This lipliner also does transfer a little bit, but its not bad at all for the price.