Great Mascara for the price

I bought a tube of this mascara a few months ago, along with all of ELF's products it was only $3.99, which is super cheap in my opinion. Its supposed to lengthen and add volume, I honestly didn't notice much a difference with either. It certainly colored my lashes, and stayed on all day without flaking/clumping, but it didn't give me the 'wow' factor that I like to have. Its not my go to mascara, there are a few others that I love and can't live without, but I probably would still buy again because its a great mascara for coloring with no clumping, for such a cheap price and just good to have on hand when I run out of my fav's.

Did not like this mascara. It was an impulse buy. Did not give and volume and length. Was waterproof that was it. The price was... you get what you paid for.

I bought this e.l.f. mascara on a whim at Walmart, because of the price and I wanted to try a new waterproof mascara. While waterproof, I find you need a few layers of product to be noticeable and to compete with other mascaras. I don't think I'll buy this one again.

I am a huge fan of e.l.f. products, but the mascara is not very good. It did not lengthen or volumize, and it was as if I was not even wearing a mascara. Even though this product is very affordable, I would skip it and purchase a higher quality mascara.

This mascara had a really thin consistency, and was really natural, not a ton of lengthening or volumizing. The issue with this though, was that it would flake off and irritate my eye.

I was looking for a brown mascara that wasn't too light or too dark and this one is perfect. It doesn't clump but can be tricky to remove but the color lasts all day. I couldn't tell if it made my lashes longer looking though but for $2 it's great in a pinch.