Not as Great as I Expected

I'm not in love with it as it is definitely not waterproof and just didn't die on as smooth as I expected. I usually like E.L.F products but this one wasn't the one for me.

Its perfect

C’est mon eye-liner préféré de tous les temps.
Je suis rendue à mon deuxième et j’en ai un en back-up dans ma collection. Il est parfait.
Il fait de belles lignes minces comme je les aime.
Celles qui désirent faire la wing,
vous serez capables étant donné que la mine est large en bas et devient fine en haut.
Il va trop bien.
Je vais m’en faire des réserves.
Aussi, il me dure bien longtemps.
Il sèche rapidement pour ne pas se promener sur la paupière.

Least expensive eyeliner I have ever purchased. Works as well and lasts as long as high end products.

I'm a true believer in a good eyeliner but I was extremely disappointed with this product. I love a select few E.L.F products, so i had high hopes for this eyeliner. First off, it wasn't waterproof at all, even letting it dry for the suggested 30 seconds. It went on smoothly and dried to a black sheen finish. Only two hours later it was half way down my face!!! It flaked, smudged and faded so much that i looked like i had a black eye :( At least i only paid a dollar!

Last all day and easy application love it

goes on smooth and lasts all day! easy to take off and price is great as well

I like this pen. It gives me precise lining abilities and goes on smooth and drys quick. It lasts all day for me with no chipping but comes off easily with any oil based makeup remover.

I love this eyeliner! It was my first try at "liquid" eyeliner but it's definitely opening my eyes to how awesome it is. I love the control I have and how great it looks for special occasions or even every day. I would recommend it anyone, however I'm not quite sure how great the waterproof aspect is because sometimes I do need to fix falling eyeliner.

This liquid eyeliner is absolutely fantastic! I love how the liner goes on in a thick coat, and is easy to apply. The best thing about this eyeliner is, it is only $1. It may seem cheap by the price, but it is a fantastic buy! I absolutely love this product. I recommend this product to anyone and everyone.

my first eyeliner pen i got from target and my second elf eyeliner pen i order it from amazon . it works so good .