For me, this sucked. It wouldn't go on in a smooth black line, it was a patchy grey mess. It would flake off during the day no matter what I put under it (tried putting it on bare lids, over eye primer, over eyeshadow, etc). Even though this is super cheap, I wouldn't recommend wasting your money.

I was really excited to give this a try because it was super cheap and looked amazing.

Sadly, that was not the case. The applicator looks like it works really well, however, it is very messy and gets all over the place.

The formula itself also looks promising, however once applied is very chalky and comes off very easily. In addition, the formula is not very opaque, and that is something that I look for in a eyeliner.

Although the price is right, it is not worth it. Spend your money on something else if you want an eyeliner that is going to make sharp lines, and last all day.